Whether or not it’s refining your corporation mannequin, mastering new applied sciences, or discovering methods to capitalize on the subsequent market surge, Inman Join New York will put together you to take daring steps ahead. The Subsequent Chapter is about to start. Be a part of it. Be a part of us and hundreds of actual property leaders Jan. 22-24, 2025.
Over the previous a number of years, the Nationwide Affiliation of Realtors (NAR) has been suffering from a collection of missteps and scandals which have left its members questioning the group’s management and integrity. From navigating disastrous lawsuits and expensive settlement agreements to implementing poorly conceived insurance policies and guidelines, the group’s management has demonstrated a sample of negligence and mismanagement.
The latest multimillion-dollar settlement stemming from antitrust lawsuits is just one instance of how NAR’s actions — or lack thereof — have left its members to pay the worth, each financially and reputationally.
Now, yet one more obvious subject has come to gentle: the exorbitant salaries paid to NAR’s so-called “volunteer” leaders. This subject isn’t only a matter of questionable ethics — it epitomizes the tradition of waste and entitlement entrenched in NAR’s management.
How can a company justify paying its “volunteers” six-figure salaries whereas members endure rising dues and a declining sense of belief? That is yet one more instance of the corruption that has pushed NAR so far, with implications that can’t be ignored.
The highest 6 paid leaders in 2022: Salaries that defy volunteerism
NAR’s lack of transparency relating to management salaries (ironic for a company that advocates transparency in actual property commissions) makes it troublesome to search out compensation particulars for 2023 or 2024. Nevertheless, based mostly on NAR’s Type 990 submitting, NAR’s compensation construction for its leaders in 2022 clearly blurred the strains between volunteer service and paid skilled roles.
Listed below are the highest six paid people holding “volunteer” or management positions:
Leslie Rouda Smith (NAR President): $413,556
Kenny Parcell (President-Elect): $265,956
Invoice Malkasian (former officer): $256,951
Dale Stinton (former officer/marketing consultant): $250,000
Nancy Lane (NAR Treasurer): $212,356
Tracy Kasper (First Vice President): $181,362
Charles Oppler (Instant Previous President): $162,344
Do these ‘volunteers’ earn greater than their actual property practices?
When the excessive salaries paid to NAR leaders first got here to gentle, NAR spokesman Mantill Williams defended the compensation, stating that these people “raise their hands to serve the industry,” which requires a “substantial time commitment, personal sacrifice and significant travel.”
Whereas this will sound noble, it fails to deal with a basic query: Are these “volunteers” making extra of their NAR roles than they did by way of their actual property practices? For a lot of, the reply is sure.
With salaries exceeding a whole bunch of hundreds of {dollars} yearly, it’s exhausting to argue that these roles align with the standard definition of volunteerism. If stepping away from their actual property companies to serve the affiliation is such a burden, as Williams states, maybe they need to not volunteer within the first place.
With 1.5 million members, certainly there are profitable, competent Realtors who might give again to the business with out demanding extreme compensation. Furthermore, if these leaders’ actual property companies had been so poorly constructed that they can not afford to step away quickly, this raises severe questions on their {qualifications} to handle a nationwide group.
NAR deserves leaders who display real dedication to serving the business — not people who deal with these roles as alternatives for private enrichment.
Current investigations have uncovered a number of situations of lavish spending by the Nationwide Affiliation of Realtors (NAR) management, elevating issues in regards to the group’s monetary practices. Verified expenditures embrace:
Broadway present tickets: NAR leaders bought tickets to fashionable Broadway reveals, equivalent to Hamilton, for themselves and relations whereas attending conferences in New York Metropolis.
First-class airfare: Executives and high-ranking leaders incessantly booked first-class flights for each themselves and their spouses throughout official journey.
Luxurious dinners: NAR bank cards had been used to cowl costly dinners, together with the acquisition of $300 bottles of wine.
Sports activities occasion tickets: Leaders acquired complimentary tickets to Chicago Cubs and Blackhawks video games throughout their stays in Chicago.
Spa remedies and golf outings: Company bank cards had been utilized to pay for spa remedies and golf outings throughout work journeys.
These expenditures have drawn sharp criticism from nonprofit watchdogs and raised severe questions on whether or not such spending is suitable for a tax-exempt group. Consultants counsel that these practices could violate tax legal guidelines prohibiting nonprofit workers and leaders from utilizing funds for private profit.
As soon as once more, NAR management is paving the best way for one more lawsuit — this time with the IRS. As a nonprofit below Part 501(c)(6) of the Inner Income Code, NAR is strictly prohibited from utilizing member dues for private luxuries equivalent to massages, golf outings and Broadway reveals.
This blatant misuse of funds not solely erodes member belief but additionally poses important authorized and monetary dangers to the group.
Why does this matter?
The NAR’s management compensation construction is a obvious outlier, elevating severe questions in regards to the group’s priorities and accountability. The stark disparity between NAR and different associations challenges its nonprofit mission and casts doubt on whether or not member dues are getting used successfully.
When our leaders are paid salaries surpassing the typical Realtor, it undermines the credibility and integrity of the group.
To once more tackle Williams’ level in regards to the sacrifices NAR leaders make to fill their positions, let’s take into account different skilled associations. The American Bar Affiliation, the American Medical Affiliation, and the American Psychological Affiliation — all representing extremely expert and busy professionals — have structured their organizations so their volunteers serve with out salaries. If medical doctors and legal professionals can volunteer their time to steer their associations with out monetary compensation, certainly NAR leaders can do the identical.
Conclusion: A name for reform
As a Realtor, it’s a must to ask your self: are you okay struggling to pay your annual dues, RPAC contributions, and different affiliation charges in order that our “volunteers” may be paid a whole bunch of hundreds of {dollars} — whereas having fun with Broadway reveals and spa remedies in your dime?
NAR should tackle these obvious points. Members deserve transparency and accountability relating to how their dues are allotted. Management salaries ought to replicate the spirit of volunteerism and align with nonprofit greatest practices, as seen in different skilled associations.
At a minimal, NAR ought to decide to publishing management salaries for 2023, 2024 and past as a result of these figures are already identified internally. Transparency in compensation is an important first step towards rebuilding belief with its members.
Simply as NAR agreed in its latest authorized settlement that brokers should be extra clear with their commissions, the group itself should uphold those self same rules of openness and honesty. Management can’t demand transparency from its members whereas failing to use these requirements to its personal monetary practices.
Till these modifications are made, NAR’s lavish spending practices will proceed to erode belief and lift severe questions on its dedication to serving its members and the actual property business somewhat than enriching its leaders.
The time for reform is now, and the duty lies squarely with NAR’s management to prioritize one of the best pursuits of their members over their very own monetary acquire. Let this text function a name for NAR management to embrace the true spirit of volunteerism—like different associations—and take $0 in compensation.
Till they do, each member ought to demand accountability and strain management relentlessly to make this transformation. Solely by taking this daring step can NAR start to rebuild belief, restore integrity, and permit the true leaders of the actual property business — these keen to serve selflessly — to rise to the event.
Darryl Davis is the CEO of Darryl Davis Seminars. Join with him on Fb or YouTube.
