When the worth topped £9 on the top of the price of dwelling disaster, it grew to become the centre of a media frenzy, with outraged buyers sharing their disbelief and supermarkets placing safety tags on tubs.
Although the worth has fallen, Lurpak retains its fame because the market-leading spreadable butter – however how does it arise towards different manufacturers and grocery store variations?
Within the newest version of Our Verdict, the Cash workforce pitted Lurpak towards 12 opponents, making an attempt every blind on bread and toast to present a rating out of 10 for style, texture and spreadability.
Two manufacturers scored the identical marks, putting them joint first – however they’ve a worth distinction of £1.20 a bathtub.
Lurpak and M&S impressed our testers, scoring a mean of 9 out of 10 factors.
On the different finish of the desk was some of the costly choices. Produced from milk from Irish grass-fed cows, Kerrygold did not impress our judges, scoring simply three out of 10.
Listed here are the complete rankings – and you’ll learn our summaries of every model under…
Joint first – Lurpak
Value: £3.50 for 250g
Common rating: 9
“Impressive”, “delicious” and “moreish” had been a number of the phrases used to explain this one. It scored extremely for its creamy texture and wealthy flavour – particularly its welcome salty aftertaste.
Picture:
Lurpak got here joint first
Joint first: M&S
Value: £2.30 for 250g
Common rating: 9
Simply how butter ought to style, with sufficient saltiness and thickness for a great sandwich. It was simple to unfold, and lasted a great period of time earlier than melting on a slice of toast.
Picture:
M&S was discovered to be simply pretty much as good
Second: Asda
Value: £2.18 for 500g
Common rating: 8.1
Not too far behind the highest spot, this one was a less expensive choice, costing £1.38 lower than Lurpak for double the quantity of butter. It was wealthy, easy and creamy, with a pleasant quantity of salt, however a few of our testers felt it was a bit too oily on toast.
Picture:
Asda obtained a mean rating of 8.1
Third: Lidl
Value: £2.18 for 500g
Common rating: 7.3
This one had our testers divided, with some discovering it lacked any flavour and others pondering it was simply salty sufficient. All of them agreed that it was simple to unfold, and had a pleasant texture and thickness to it.
Picture:
Our testers had been divided over Lidl’s providing
Joint fourth: Yeo Valley
Value: £4.75 for 400g
Common rating: 7
A assured crowd pleaser – however nothing to make it outshine the competitors. You’ll be able to’t go unsuitable with it in your toast or in your sandwiches, however if you need one thing that stands out, this may not meet your expectations.
Picture:
Yeo Valley was a crowd pleaser
Joint fourth: Aldi
Value: £2.18 for 500g
Common rating: 7
Contemplating its rating in the identical place as Yeo Valley, you undoubtedly get extra bang on your buck with Aldi’s own-brand choice. It melted properly on toast, taking its time and never leaving a foul oily residue.
It had a great degree of salt, nevertheless it lacked any tingle and had a touch of margarine in its style.
Picture:
Aldi was crushed by its price range retail rival
Fifth: Anchor
Value: £4.45 for 400g
Common rating: 5.6
It had the feel and appear of margarine, and regardless of a lovely creaminess, it underwhelmed flavour-wise.
Picture:
Anchor obtained a rating of 5.6
Sixth: Morrisons
Value: £1.96 for 450g
Common rating: 5.5
This one divided our testers – with a brighter yellow color promising a lot. Some thought it was nice, others felt it lacked style.
Picture:
Morrisons divided our testers
Seventh: Tesco
Value: £2.18 for 500g
Common rating: 5.2
Inoffensive – however our testers felt it tasted each bit the price range choice and was extra paying homage to margarine than butter.
Picture:
‘Inoffensive’ was the very best phrase for this one
Eighth: Countrylife
Value: £4.50 for 500g
Common rating: 4.6
Approach too spreadable for faux-butter, so it felt oily. The color was anaemic, however our tasters did just like the salt ranges.
Picture:
Countrylife: Salty and oily
Joint ninth: Sainsbury’s
Value: £2.18 for 500g
Common rating: 3.6
The sturdy buttery odor led our testers right into a false sense of confidence in how this one would style – however they ended up dissatisfied in uncooked, bread and toast tastings.
Picture:
Sainsbury’s got here joint ninth
Joint ninth: Waitrose
Value: £2.75 for 500g
Common rating: 3.6
The very first thing our testers observed was its nearly bitter odor, which most discovered off-putting. It was fairly bland in style, however in case you are a butter purist and don’t need saltiness, this could be for you.
Picture:
It is a good choice for ‘butter purists’
Final place: Kerrygold
Value: £3.75 for 400g
Common rating: 3
It was a promising begin with the golden look of a correct hunk of butter, however the flavour did not match. It had an nearly bitter aftertaste, leaving a few of our testers gasping for a drink.
Picture:
Kerrygold scored the bottom marks
